Payment to ANA in settlement

This article was originally printed in Numismatic News.
>> Subscribe today!

The litigation between former American Numismatic Association Executive Director Christopher Cipoletti and the ANA has been resolved by settlement, which included the payment of money by Cipoletti to the ANA. Terms of the settlement are confidential.

“I’m pleased to report that after nearly six years, we can finally focus all of our efforts on our educational mission and serving the members of our esteemed Association,” said Executive Director Larry Shepherd.

The settlement marks the end of a lengthy legal saga that began in July 2005 when Cipoletti filed suit against former ANA employees and a former ANA vendor. Cipoletti was dismissed as executive director of the ANA for cause on Oct. 15, 2007, and the lawsuit against the former ANA employees was resolved to the mutual satisfaction of the parties in July, 2008.

Cipoletti filed an arbitration case seeking additional payment under his employment contract. A May 27, 2009, decision by American Arbitration Association Arbitrator Kathryn E. Miller held that Cipoletti was terminated for cause and that he breached his fiduciary duties to the ANA. On July 29, 2009, the Arbitrator issued a second decision that held that Cipoletti must pay $53,550.26 to cover the expenses of the arbitration.

In September 2009, El Paso County District Court Judge Thomas K. Kane confirmed both of the arbitrator’s decisions. Cipoletti then appealed the Judge’s ruling on the arbitration case.

A third suit in which a Denver law firm, Davis, Graham and Stubbs, filed for legal fees against the ANA led to the ANA filing a counterclaim for breach of fiduciary duties against DGS and Cipoletti.

The litigation between the ANA and DGS was settled to the parties’ mutual satisfaction. This most recent settlement resolves all pending lawsuits.