World Coin Clinic: How Coin Auctions Work
From English and Japanese auctions to the descending-price Dutch system, there’s more than one way to sell a coin or collectible.
Is our public auction system, through which coins are sold, the only auction system out there?
There are two types of auctions: one being public, the other private. A private auction is invitation-only, while a public auction is open to anyone. The auction system through which coins are traditionally sold is the English auction system. There are two additional systems used when selling other items.
What are the other two auction systems?
Japanese auctions use an elimination process in which the price changes in increments and participants drop out of the bidding, while the Dutch auction system is a descending rather than an ascending system, unlike the English system we commonly use.
How does the Dutch auction system work?
The Dutch Reverse auction system is typically used when selling flowers to wholesalers. It involves the auctioneer suggesting an initial price that is typically very high. The auctioneer slowly lowers the price until an individual accepts that price. The bidding then stops. That initial bid is the winner.
What is different about the Japanese auction system?
All participating bidders are required to accept a baseline price in the Japanese system. The auctioneer then raises that price in increments. Bidders willing to pay that price continue; however, bidders not willing to pay that price will begin to drop out. As the price increases, more bidders will continue to drop out until a single bidder remains. That bidder will be declared the winner.
Are there things about the English auction system we should be aware of?
Three things of importance that bidders may not be aware of within the English Ascending auction system are that bids are meant to remain within the specific increments as determined by the auctioneer. Bidders who drop out are not, under most circumstances, allowed back into the bidding for a specific item. There may be an undisclosed reserve or minimum price set on an item, and what appears to be the hammer price for that item might be that reserve rather than a bidder’s offer.
What is a sealed bid auction and is it used to sell coins?
There are first-price and second-price sealed-bid auctions. The first-price sealed-bid auction involves each bidder submitting a single confidential bid without knowing the bids offered by competitors. The high bidder is the winner. The second-price sealed-bid auction once again involves submitting a single confidential bid; however, the bidder pays the price of the second-highest bid. The second system encourages bidders to offer what they truly believe to be the top price they will pay. I have never seen this system used to sell coins, but I don’t see why it couldn’t be used.
E-mail inquiries to Giedroyc@Bright.net. Because of space limitations, we are unable to publish all questions.
Find more World Coin Clinic here:









