Item of the Week: Civil War resulted in two three-cent types
The Civil War brought two very different three-cent coins into circulation in 1865, leaving collectors with an intriguing contrast in rarity and value.


In 1865, there were two very different U.S. three-cent coins, which created very different challenges for collectors. You might question whether having a three-cent coin in 1865 was helpful to a nation torn by civil war. The Civil War was not caused by three-cent coins, but the case could be made that it caused the creation of two types of three-cent coins in one year.
There was no compelling reason for a three-cent coin when it was introduced in 1851, except that it used a small amount of silver and could actually circulate, as initially it was just 75 percent silver. The 90 percent silver coins were not circulating, but when their silver value was changed slightly, the three-cent piece was moved to 90 percent. With things back to normal, the silver three-cent coin was not especially needed, as was evidenced by the fact that no 90 percent silver three-cent coin had a mintage over 1.5 million.
The Civil War, however, created another circulation crisis. People in both the North and the South were hoarding everything. The 90 percent silver three-cent coin was not very much silver, but it was silver, and that meant it disappeared.
The crisis in circulation produced a clever, but basic response on the part of officials. The first 75 percent silver three-cent coins may have paved the way in official thinking for what happened. The idea was simple: if people hoard silver, make coins out of other metals so they will not hoard them. The Founding Fathers wanted coins to be solid in metal value as compared to their face value, but by the mid-1800s that mattered less and officials took full advantage.
They struck first in 1864, creating a two-cent coin and changing the cent from copper-nickel to bronze. You can almost hear the officials saying, “Let’s see if they hoard that.” People did not, at least not in numbers, as the new bronze cents and two-cent pieces circulated.
The decision to create a copper-nickel three-cent coin followed in 1865, and in 1866 came the new copper-nickel nickel. Officials were more daring as the three-cent coin was replacing a silver coin and the new nickel replaced the silver half dime. It was one thing to tinker with the cent and create a new two-cent piece, but to replace silver coins with copper-nickel coins was another matter.
When officials produced 11,382,000 new copper-nickel 1865 three-cent coins, they also produced 8,500 silver three-cent coins. It was not the first time that coins of the same denomination but different compositions had been produced in the same year, but it was theorized that replacing a silver coin with a copper-nickel one might not go over all that well, which is probably why the silver version was still produced.
The two three-cent coins of 1865 are not just a contrast in metal. They are also a contrast in scarcity, as their mintages suggest. The 1865 silver three-cent coin is tough in any grade, with even a G-4 now listing at $460. In MS-65, the 90 percent silver three cents is now $5,500.
While not expensive, the 1865 copper-nickel three-cent coin is a relatively unknown key in proof. In G-4, it is just $11 and only $700 in MS-65. In Proof-65, it is $4,150 and has generally been a bit higher than the 90 percent silver three-cent coin. The reasons are estimated proof mintages of 500 for the proof silver and 400 for the copper-nickel. That can make for some interesting questions as to which 1865 three-cent piece is better, but whatever the grade, at least one has a great deal to offer, and both are certainly historic.
Looking for more "Item of the Week" articles?









