• seperator

Coins of U.S. Christmas Past

One of Walter Breen’s Christmas stocking stuffers: Gorgeous Numismatic Guaranty Corporation Proof-64 1880 Trade dollar. (Image courtesy Stack’s-Bowers)

Coins, medals and tokens have long been given as Christmas gifts. For some, the origin of the custom lies with the gifts the Magi brought to newborn Baby Jesus. For others, the tradition is linked with the giving of coins by St. Nicholas, the prototype Santa Claus of the 4th century.

But whatever its beginnings, the tradition became well-entrenched throughout Europe. From there, it arrived in the Americas where, by the 19th and 20th centuries, it had become commonplace. The striking of low-mintage proof and specimen U.S. coins in the last quarter of a year is linked to their use as Christmas gifts.

A scan of auction catalogs over the past decade provides numerous examples of coins claiming to have such a Christmas connection. Among these are an 1885 gold dollar, 1885 specimen and proof Morgan dollars, an 1889 proof Morgan dollar, 1898 and 1899 proof Morgan dollars, an 1891 gold $2.50, and even a 1907 wire rim Saint-Gaudens double eagle.

Of particular note are U.S. Trade dollars, none of which were issued for overseas use after 1878. Instead, all trade dollars struck between 1879 and 1883 were produced to satisfy the numismatic community. In his Encyclopedia of Proof and Colonial Gold Coins, Walter Breen notes while many of these were produced early in the year for inclusion in proof sets, “that around Christmas time large quantities were made presumably for stocking stuffers.”

Top and bottom of remarkable box coin made from 1877 Trade dollar. Inside a picture of a stage set showing a Japanese garden is inscribed “CONRIED / CHRISTMAS / 1907” suggesting it was made as a Christmas gift for https://amzn.to/2Qce6kJ, manager-director of the Met in 1907. The edges of the box are most obvious in the reverse image. (Images courtesy Stack’s Bowers)

Some such gifted Trade dollars were far more than mere stocking stuffers. One example sold by Stack’s Bowers consisted of an 1877-S Trade dollar that had been converted into a hollowed out box coin complete with hinged lid. The inside lid had been exquisitely engraved with a theatrical stage setting of a Japanese garden. At the top is the name CONRIED with CHRISTMAS 1907 at left and right. At the base is the signature of Max Meyer, NY.

Heinrich Conried was the manager-director of the New York Metropolitan Opera House in 1907. In February that year, the Met premiered a new version of Puccini’s “Madame Butterfly.” It was performed seven further times throughout the year, concluding with a performance on Dec. 14. The lead roles were taken by Enrico Caruso and Geraldine Farrar.

The S-B cataloger proposed that one of those involved in the production commissioned Meyer to produce this delightful miniature work of art as a Christmas gift for Conried. If this was the case, it may well have been Caruso. He was, after all, a coin collector.

Outer and inner of the Booker T. Washington Birthplace Committee 1947 Christmas card. The cutout shows a 1946 Booker T. Washington Memorial commemorative half dollar. The inner card carries an extended quote from Washington on the meaning of Christmas. (Images courtesy Stack’s Bowers)

Come the 20th century, the inclusion of U.S. coins in cutout Christmas cards became fashionable. Among some of the better-known examples were those produced by the Booker T. Washington Birthplace Committee. Two appear occasionally at auction and correspond with the 1946 first-issue Washington half dollar (above) and the 1951 first release of the George Washington Carver/Booker T. Washington half (below).

The 1951 George Washington Carver/Booker T. Washington commemorative half dollar that came housed in a six-color Christmas card holder from the Booker T. Washington Birthplace Committee in 1952. (Images courtesy Stack’s Bowers)

Washington writings contain frequent observations on the importance of Christmas in his own and America’s life. The 1946 card carries a typical, if somewhat lengthy, quotation concerning the real gift of Christmas. It is summarized neatly as: “Good Will, The First and Best Christmas Gift.”

May readers – and collectors – feel it in full this Christmas.


This article was originally printed in World Coin News. >> Subscribe today.


 Coins Magazine
If you like what you’ve read here, we invite you to visit our online bookstore to learn more about Coins Magazine.
Learn more >>>



NumismaticNews.net is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com and affiliated websites.

Tags: , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply