From the Numismatic News 60th Anniversary Special Issue – Richard Becker • Davie, Fla.
It was 1962, I had been married six months and I had been collecting coins for about a year with a specific interest in Canada.
Not being very knowledgeable regarding U.S. coins I asked her why it was priced so high. She showed me a U.S. Red Book that said it was worth $200 in the lowest grade.
However this coin was damaged. I remember it had all details showing but the edge had been crimped in several places where it looked like it had been used as a screwdriver.
I pointed this out to her and I told her that I would offer her 10 percent of the Red Book price due to the damage. I felt that I could possibly trade it to one of my collecting friends for some Canadian coin that would be worth more than that.
She agreed and I went home with it for $20. I later traded the 1802 U.S. 5-cent silver piece for some really “keen” Canadian cents that I needed for my collection.
It was not until some years later that I realized that I had purchased, and traded off, a much rarer coin than I ever imagined at that time.
Today it is considered one of the major U.S. rarities and, even damaged, would bring thousands of dollars in any auction.