• seperator

Coin Clinic: Grading Morgan dollars


By Richard Giedroyc


newmorganI am told Morgan dollars are hard to grade since quality varied from year to year and from mint to mint. What should I look for in a coin that is supposed to be uncirculated?
According to the PCGS Official Guide to Coin Grading and Counterfeit Detection, “AU55/58 Morgan dollars have slight friction on the hair below LIBERTY, the hair above the ear, and the cheek. Reverse wear is noted on the eagle’s head, breast, wing tips, legs, and claws.” This is a general statement that doesn’t take into account years or mints where the coins are notoriously poorly struck, but it is a good general guideline.

Getting started in coin collecting is as easy as 1, 2, 3 when you get your advice straight from the Answer Man of coin collecting.

Getting started in coin collecting is as easy as 1, 2, 3 when you get your advice straight from the Answer Man of coin collecting.

I see slabbed common date silver dollars at coin shows for prices that are near the cost of slabbing the coins. How can a dealer sell them at so low a price?
Some dealers make arrangements to submit large numbers of coins to a third- party certification service at deep discounts. They are counting on enough coins to be returned at a grade (and therefore a retail value) high enough to cover the cost of the coins that “didn’t make the grade.” The coins you see offered are those that the dealer needs to blow out due to their assigned grade being disappointing. From a collector’s view, yes, when considering the cost of slabbing them they are a bargain.”

I’ve asked several dealers at coin shows for a specific coin, only to be told they have one at their shop, but didn’t bring it. Why wouldn’t a dealer want to bring a full representation of his inventory?
It’s strictly a matter of practicality. Dealers attend coin shows to make money. Coin collectors attend to build or liquidate their collections. Dealers tend to bring their more expensive coins, or coins they know from past experience are more likely to sell. While some dealers work closely with the public others attend to make large, high value transactions with other dealers, or with collectors whom they pre-arranged to meet. One thing is certain, it is not possible to bring a shop’s entire inventory.

More Coin Collecting Resources:

• Get exclusive collectors’ value packs at special discounts for investing in collectible coins, world coin collectors and North American coin collectors

• Get the 2012 Coin of the Year – limited quantities remain!

• Get them instantly! Buy digital editions of past issues of World Coin News, Coins Magazine and Coin Market eXpress!


  • Subscribe to Numismatic News

    Get a full year — that’s 40 issues — of Numismatic News for only $29.99

  • More Numismatic Magazines

    Numismatic News Express

    Coins Magazine

    Bank Note Reporter

    World Coin News

    Customer Service

  • Answer our latest poll question

  • Community Voice

    You have a voice with us. Make your opinion heard on current coin collecting news and events, and get published.

  • Letters to the Editor

    • Letters to the Editor (6/16/2015) Should poorly struck silver proof sets be returned?I recently received my annual 2015 silver proof sets from the Mint. Upon inspection I became aware of the poor strikes on the obverse of the quarters (five total coins).Out of the two sets I order...
    Register today to submit a letter to the editor!
  • Marketplace Links

    Coin & Paper Money Classifieds

    Place an ad to buy or sell coins online in our classifieds section.

    Numismatic Directory

    Browse our industry directory of coin dealers online, world coin dealers, paper money dealers, coin collecting supplies, coin auctions and more.

    Numismaster Coin Price Guide

    Look up coin values with the Numismaster coin price guide.

    Coin & Paper Money Auctions

    Check out upcoming coin auctions.